No one would actually say the words on Wednesday night when beloved commentator Jerry Remy returned to Fenway Park for a visit after being out for most of the season, but the reason that he's not been in the booth for a long time is because he's been "mentally ill" not because of his lung cancer. The stigma lives on; and even in this age of Prozac we can't bear to say the words. They bring up too much baggage and fear.
Of course, officially Remy is recovering from lung cancer (check the nesn.com website) and that's the truth, but it isn't the whole truth. The fact is that a cancer diagnosis comes with a whole load of psychological baggage whether you officially recover from the cancer or not (I can personally attest to this). Certainly if you had any problems relating to your own sense of mortality before, then a cancer diagnosis particularly slaps you in the face. His cancer has been "cured," but the effects of the cancer live on.
Not that Remy himself has ducked the issues that have been plaguing him. In an interview Wednesday, he freely admitted that he'd been depressed and, though he has been working his way out of it, it is still an on-going issue. He said this in the plain, straight-ahead style that makes him so loved her in New England. He didn't duck the issue but everyone around him did.
It's has to be tough having Reny's job in particular. No one wants to hear that the color guy isn't just thrilled to be at the park for yet another wonderful baseball game. Being upbeat is a job requirement for someone with Remy's job and this makes things even more hazardous for him because no one is happy and "on" all of the time but the expectation is that he will be. The pressure not to disappoint well-wishers must be immense.
The mental health issue hits too close to home with people I guess. We can become physically ill and not change too much who you think you are. But mental illness is something else - it strikes directly at your own perception of who you are and, sometimes more importantly, who other people think you are. And if you get the label, it can stick for life.
And if Jerry can become sick and confused and depressed so that he can't function, then it can happen to any of us and no one wants to believe that. Unfortunately, this also means that people who have been designated as "mentally ill" have to put up with being labeled for the rest of their lives as people who can't be trusted because they're "nuts."
If it can happen to Jerry Remy, it can happen to any of us. Scary and still under the table.